- Casino
- By State
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- Georgia
- Florida
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Massachusetts
- Maryland
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
- By State
- Slots
- Poker
- Sports
- Esports
Fact-checked by Stoyan Todorov
Wynn Resorts Prevails in Legal Dispute Over Slot Machine Payouts
The lawsuit, which spanned several years, focused on claims made by plaintiff A. Richard Schuster that the casino's ticket redemption practices violated Massachusetts consumer protection laws
Wynn Resorts has won a legal battle against its casino, Encore Boston Harbor, over slot machine payouts.
Court Confirms Encore Boston Harbor’s Ticket Redemption Practices Are Lawful
The lawsuit, which lasted for several years centered on claims by plaintiff A. Richard Schuster that the casino’s ticket redemption practices broke Massachusetts consumer protection laws. Schuster claimed that the casino’s refusal to give out coins at its ticket redemption units (TRUs) when cashing in slot machine vouchers cheated customers.
The US First Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the casino did not break any laws backing earlier court decisions that sided with Wynn Resorts. Circuit Judge Lara Montecalvo led the three-judge panel, which agreed that Schuster’s claims had no legal basis.
The problem came from the casino’s TRUs. These machines did not give out exact change. Instead, they printed a second voucher for any leftover amount under a dollar. Players could cash in this extra voucher at a cashier’s window or put it in another machine. Schuster argued that this setup broke both the casino’s own rules and Massachusetts gambling laws. He said it misled customers by not giving them full cash payouts.
Schuster Faces Defeat Once More Against Wynn Resorts
This lawsuit was the newest in a string of legal challenges Schuster brought against Encore Boston Harbor.
Wynn moved the case to federal court. A district judge ruled in favor of the casino earlier this year. The court heard Schuster’s appeal in January 2024 and made its final decision in September. The First Circuit decided that Encore’s redemption practices matched industry standards and did not break federal or state laws. The ruling pointed out that Massachusetts gaming rules allow vouchers to be seen as a type of “funds” under the law. This meant the casino’s actions were legal.
Schuster’s earlier complaints had an impact on the odds of the Encore Boston Harbor casino’s blackjack games. Schuster argued about the casino adding 6:5 odds to its blackjack tables. This setup does not favor players as much as the usual 3:2 odds. After he lost this claim, Schuster turned his attention to how the slot machines paid out winnings. But he ended up losing in court again.
With the chances of the US Supreme Court taking up the case looking slim, this ruling might end Schuster’s legal fight. The decision backs Encore Boston Harbor’s business methods confirming that its operations follow Massachusetts’ rules.
Related Topics:
Silvia has dabbled in all sorts of writing – from content writing for social media to movie scripts. She has a Bachelor's in Screenwriting and experience in marketing and producing documentary films. With her background as a customer support agent within the gambling industry, she brings valuable insight to the Gambling News writers’ team.
Previous Article
Casino
September 25, 2024
Stats Perform Secures Video Betting Rights for SPFL and SWPL
Next Article
Casino
September 25, 2024
New York Lawmakers React Strongly Over DraftKings’ Fee on Winning Bets
Must Read
Casino
February 13, 2025
Kewadin Casinos Slowly Recovering After Devastating Cyberattack
Casino
February 14, 2025
Boyd Gaming Acquires Land Under Eastside Cannery
More Articles
Industry
February 18, 2025
Betting Expansion Fuels Rise in Gambling Addiction Searches
Casino
February 18, 2025
Thailand Makes Changes to Casino Bill to Deal with Public Concerns
Lottery
February 17, 2025
Washington’s Lottery Achieves Top Responsible Gambling Certification
Industry
February 17, 2025
Coinbase CEO: Prediction Markets Are a Better Source of Truth
Industry
February 17, 2025
Las Vegas Drunk Driver Sentenced After Deadly Car Accident
Industry
February 17, 2025
New Jersey iGaming Expanded, Sports Betting Slowed Down in January
Industry
February 17, 2025
Detroit: City Offers Aid After Child Freezing Tragedy at Casino
Industry
February 17, 2025
Nostalgia Attracts Players, Top Mechanics Keep Them Hooked
Industry
February 17, 2025
Nevada’s Rep. Horsford Pushes TIPS Act for Fair Wages
Industry
February 17, 2025
Breaking Down the 2025 NY Casino License Race and Bidders
Legal
February 14, 2025
Koin and Everi Pause Litigation to Explore Settlement Options
Casino
February 14, 2025
ACMA Moves Against Offshore Gambling Sector in Australia