At the start of the month, Wynn Resorts and Related Companies’ Hudson Yards West project made an important step forward after receiving approval from the City Planning Commission (CPC).
This week, a large group of West Side residents packed City Hall, determined to voice their opposition to the controversial redevelopment plan that would place a casino and thousands of housing units above Hudson Yards West.
Fears of Neighborhood Overshadowing
The proposal, which has evolved significantly since its original 2009 version, includes 4,000 new residential units and a 5.6-acre park.
Developers argue that the updates are necessary because the initial plan no longer makes financial sense.
They claim the revised project would generate massive economic benefits, including billions in funding for the Metropolitan Transport Authority, around 30,000 construction jobs, and much-needed housing.
However, local residents see things very differently. Many say the sheer scale of the project would literally overshadow the neighborhood.
They’re particularly concerned that the towering development would block sunlight from reaching the High Line and the planned green space, leaving once-bright areas in shadow.
Casinos Don’t Belong in Residential Neighborhoods, Say Locals
More than the physical footprint, though, it’s the inclusion of a casino that has sparked the most outrage. Longtime locals say a gambling venue has no place in a family-oriented residential area.
Similarly to small business owners who also voiced their opposition, residents worry a casino would impact their livelihoods and significantly alter the character of Manhattan’s West Side.
Pushing back against the criticism, developers highlighted the potential broader economic impact of the project, framing it as an important investment in public infrastructure and citywide recovery.
Nonetheless, many members of the community argue that both the social and environmental costs would likely outweigh the promised benefits.
The Battle for a Casino License
In addition to seeking support from the City Council, the proposal requires a state-issued gaming license for the casino to open.
Provided the project passes the final stage of the City’s Uniform Land Use Review Procedure, the bid will seek approval from the City Council, which may come within 60 days.
If the final approval is granted, the proposed casino development will be reviewed as one of the bidders for a gaming license. The three coveted licenses will then be awarded by the end of the year.
Albany lawmakers will ultimately decide which proposals move forward.
For opponents, the fight won’t stop even if the casino is removed from the plan. The debate is far from over, but one thing is clear: West Side residents won’t back down from fighting for the future of their community.